The PING PLD Milled Anser is a premium blade machined from a solid block of 303 stainless steel over four-plus hours of CNC milling, and it earns an 8.7 consensus score on the strength of feel reviewers compare directly to Scotty Cameron, the most iconic shape in golf, and a Golf Digest Hot List gold medal. But it's a traditional blade, so forgiveness is its built-in weakness — Plugged In Golf warned that "large mishits will end up short," and there's no face insert or adjustable weighting to rescue off-center strikes at $450. The 2024 update is also purely cosmetic over the original (same head, same weighting), and the significant toe hang makes it a poor match for straight-back, straight-through strokes. If you love the Anser look but want more forgiveness, a lower price, modern tech, or a stroke-friendlier design, the alternatives below each beat it on a specific axis.
Stick with the PLD Milled Anser if you...
Look at an alternative if you...
| # | Putter | Score | Price | Better for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | PING Scottsdale Anser | 8.7 | $270 | Same Anser shape, cheaper, more forgiving |
| 2 | TaylorMade Spider ZT | 9.2 | $400 | Maximum forgiveness and face stability |
| 3 | Titleist Super Select Newport 2 | 9.4 | $449 | Elite resale plus tungsten adjustability |
| 4 | L.A.B. Golf DF3 | 9.1 | $449 | Zero-torque face control for any stroke |
| 5 | Odyssey Ai-One Milled Seven T | 9.1 | $350 | Milled feel plus AI-insert consistency |
| 6 | PING Scottsdale Prime Tyne 4 | 8.9 | $270 | Budget lag-putting mallet, far more forgiving |
| PING PLD Milled AnserThe club you're replacing | 8.7 | $450 | Elite milled feel, but pricey and low on forgiveness |
It's the same iconic PING Anser silhouette you came for, but the lightweight Pebax insert frees up weight that PING redistributes to the heel and toe for up to 11% higher MOI than the PLD Milled Anser, so it twists noticeably less on off-center strikes. MyGolfSpy ranked it the #2 blade overall and best from mid-range, and at $269.99 it undercuts the PLD by $180 while including a SuperStroke grip. If the PLD's price and thin forgiveness are what's stopping you, this is the closest, smartest swap on the board.
Read full review →Check price at Amazon→Where the PLD is a low-MOI blade, the Spider ZT is a 5,000-MOI zero-torque mallet engineered to keep the face square without manipulation, directly answering the PLD's biggest knock that 'large mishits will end up short.' It finished #2 in MyGolfSpy's zero-torque test and won the 2025 Valero Texas Open in its debut week with Brian Harman, with lag putting that feels nearly automatic. It's also built for the straight-back, straight-through stroke the PLD's toe hang fights — the trade-off being a muted feel rather than the PLD's crisp tock.
Read full review →Check price at Amazon→The PLD was built to challenge this putter on feel at the same price, and for buyers who want the name the Cameron answers two things the PLD can't: customizable tungsten sole weights (the PLD has none) and resale value that holds 70-80% of retail. MyGolfSpy ranked it the #1 blade for feel, sound, and looks, with the best long-range PuttView Handicap of any blade tested thanks to its dual-milled face. It's still a blade, so forgiveness is comparable; you're paying for craftsmanship, adjustability, and brand cachet, not added stability.
Read full review →Check price at Amazon→If your real problem is the blade's toe hang twisting the face open and closed, the DF3's Lie Angle Balance puts the center of gravity under the shaft so the face has zero tendency to rotate; reviewers called it 'the closest thing to a cheat code in putting' and forum users reported dropping 4-6 strokes a round. Crucially, it works with any stroke shape, including the straight-back, straight-through path the PLD's toe hang penalizes. It's the same $449 as the PLD but adds handmade-in-Oregon build and near-limitless customization, with the catches being an unconventional look and a genuine fitting and adjustment period.
Read full review →Check price→This is the answer to the PLD's 'no face insert' knock without giving up milled construction: a 100% CNC-milled 303 stainless steel body paired with an AI-designed titanium insert that Odyssey says finishes putts 10% closer to the hole and improves lag putting by up to 20%. It adds the forgiveness of a fang-style mallet, interchangeable 5-20g sole weights for fitting, and a firmer, responsive feel, all for $100 less than the PLD. National Club Golfer called its navy PVD finish 'absolutely stunning' behind the ball.
Read full review →Check price→For golfers willing to trade the blade for stability on long putts, the Prime Tyne 4 was MyGolfSpy's #3 mallet for 2025, posting standout -8.7 medium and -10.5 long PuttView Handicap numbers, exactly the lag-range forgiveness a blade can't match. Its twin-fork perimeter weighting delivers up to 11% higher MOI than the PLD Milled equivalent, and it's another PING built for strong-arc strokes at just $269.99. Note it's heel-shafted for rotation, so straight-back putters should skip it and look to the Spider ZT or DF3 instead.
Read full review →Check price at Amazon→Prices checked at Amazon & major golf retailers — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Disclosure.
We started from what the PLD Milled Anser does well and where it falls short, then searched our database of reviewed putters for the ones that beat it on a single, specific axis a real golfer cares about. Every pick has a full review on this site, and every score is our transparent consensus number: 35% expert reviews, 25% data-driven testing, 30% forum/community opinion, 10% retail — see the methodology. No pay-for-placement. No fabricated scores.
Editorial independence: Reading the Break is not affiliated with any golf equipment manufacturer. Our scores are never influenced by affiliate relationships. Some links on this page are affiliate links — if you buy through them, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure.
Compare these head-to-head, or see how they rank across the field.