The TaylorMade Spider ZT is the brand's first zero-torque putter, marrying the iconic Spider mallet shape to a center-of-gravity shaft that keeps the face square through the stroke with no manipulation. It earns a 9.2 consensus score on the strength of elite 5K-MOI stability, the best long-putt result in MyGolfSpy's 17-putter zero-torque test, full marks for roll and distance control, and looks reviewers call the best in the zero-torque category — plus a 2025 Valero Texas Open win in Brian Harman's bag. The honest knocks send a lot of golfers shopping: the Pure Roll insert feels soft and muted rather than crisp or poppy, short putts inside 10 feet rank below average, the ~$400 price is a real premium, and the zero-torque geometry fights players with an arcing stroke. If any of those land for you, the alternatives below each beat the Spider ZT on a specific axis.
Stick with the Spider ZT if you...
Look at an alternative if you...
| # | Putter | Score | Price | Better for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Titleist Super Select Newport 2 | 9.4 | $449 | Crisp milled feel for arc strokes |
| 2 | L.A.B. Golf DF3 | 9.1 | $449 | Sharper short putts, true zero-torque |
| 3 | TaylorMade Spider Tour | 8.8 | $350 | Same Spider look, cheaper, arc-friendly |
| 4 | PING Scottsdale Prime Tyne 4 | 8.9 | $270 | Most MOI per dollar for arc players |
| 5 | Odyssey Ai-One Milled Seven T | 9.1 | $350 | Responsive milled feel, still forgiving |
| 6 | PING PLD Milled Anser | 8.7 | $450 | Crisp tock feedback inside 10 feet |
| TaylorMade Spider ZTThe club you're replacing | 9.2 | $400 | Stellar long-range stability, but soft feel and weak short putts |
Where the Spider ZT's Pure Roll insert reads soft and muted under 20 feet, the Super Select Newport 2 is MyGolfSpy's top-ranked blade for feel — a dual-milled face that Today's Golfer called 'second to absolutely nobody.' Its timeless Anser 2 shape is built to set up for the slight-arc strokes the zero-torque Spider actively resists. You give up some MOI and forgiveness, but you get the most rewarding feedback in putting.
Read full review →Check price at Amazon→If you love the zero-torque concept but the Spider ZT's below-average short-putt numbers are the dealbreaker, the DF3 is the putter the whole category was chasing. Its Lie Angle Balance tech made putts inside three feet feel near-automatic for Golf Monthly, and GolfMagic said it improved putting most from 10 feet and in — exactly the range where the Spider ZT lags. You keep the face-square-through-impact stability while gaining the short-range confidence the Spider gives up.
Read full review →Check price→For the golfer drawn to the Spider shape but not the zero-torque commitment, the standard Spider Tour brings TaylorMade's highest MOI, the same True Path alignment, and the same Pure Roll insert — but with a traditional slant neck that suits an arcing stroke and a price $50 under the ZT. Adjustable sole weights let you dial in head weight the fixed ZT can't. It's the Spider for players who want the stability without the center-shaft feel.
Read full review →Check price→At $270 the Prime Tyne 4 undercuts the Spider ZT by $130 yet still delivers elite stability — MyGolfSpy named it the #3 mallet of 2025, and its twin-fork shape posts up to 11% higher MOI than PING's own PLD Milled. The heel-shafted hosel is purpose-built for the strong-arc strokes the zero-torque Spider fights, and the Pebax insert rolls soft and consistent in any temperature. The value play for golfers who live and die by lag putting.
Read full review →Check price at Amazon→The answer for players who want feedback without dropping to a blade: the Ai-One Milled Seven T's milled titanium insert produces a firmer, more responsive strike than the Spider ZT's dampened Pure Roll face, while AI-designed face contours normalize ball speed for tighter distance control. National Club Golfer called the navy PVD finish 'absolutely stunning,' and the fang shape keeps mallet-level forgiveness — at $50 less than the ZT. A premium mallet that actually talks back at impact.
Read full review →Check price→The most direct fix for the Spider ZT's dull, muted impact: the PLD Milled Anser's four-hour-milled Deep AMP face produces a crisp 'tock' that gets predictably louder on longer putts and tells you exactly where you struck it — the feedback channel the Spider's soft insert mutes. It's a tour-proven blade (Hovland, Finau, Watson) with craftsmanship GolfWRX members say rivals Scotty Cameron. The trade is blade-level forgiveness for genuine blade-level feel.
Read full review →Check price at Amazon→Prices checked at Amazon & major golf retailers — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Disclosure.
We started from what the Spider ZT does well and where it falls short, then searched our database of reviewed putters for the ones that beat it on a single, specific axis a real golfer cares about. Every pick has a full review on this site, and every score is our transparent consensus number: 35% expert reviews, 25% data-driven testing, 30% forum/community opinion, 10% retail — see the methodology. No pay-for-placement. No fabricated scores.
Editorial independence: Reading the Break is not affiliated with any golf equipment manufacturer. Our scores are never influenced by affiliate relationships. Some links on this page are affiliate links — if you buy through them, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure.
Compare these head-to-head, or see how they rank across the field.