Tommy Armour Impact No. 2 Putter
A traditional blade putter named after a Golf Hall of Famer — Tommy Armour's Impact No. 2 delivers a classic heel-toe weighted design with a soft face insert at the most accessible price point in our putter rankings.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link — it never affects our scores or the price you pay.
The consensus
The Tommy Armour Impact No. 2 is a budget blade putter that offers the most accessible price point in our putter rankings at $150. Carrying the name of Silver Scot Tommy Armour — a three-time major winner who was inducted into the World Golf Hall of Fame — the Impact No. 2 delivers a traditional heel-toe weighted blade design with a soft insert face and a plumber's neck hosel that provides moderate toe hang. For beginners, casual golfers, and budget-conscious players who need a functional blade, it gets the job done.
The honest assessment: the Tommy Armour Impact No. 2 performs adequately for its purpose and price, but it faces tough competition from slightly more expensive alternatives that deliver noticeably better technology. The Wilson Infinite Buckingham at $180 delivers face milling, a higher-MOI design, and an included oversized grip that outperforms the Tommy Armour across every performance category. Forum users who directly compared the two consistently chose to spend the extra $30. For $150, the Tommy Armour works — it rolls the ball forward, it looks like a putter, and it doesn't embarrass itself.
Where it struggles: build quality and feel. The cast construction shows finish inconsistencies, and the impact character is muted in a way that doesn't provide informative feedback about strike quality. The face insert is soft but thin, and experienced golfers will notice the material difference versus quality insert putters. There's no fitting program, no custom options, and no aftermarket support pathway. The Tommy Armour Impact No. 2 is exactly what it is: an honest entry-level blade at the lowest price tier, best suited for players who need a functional starting point or a budget-friendly introduction to the blade putter category.
A traditional blade putter named after a Golf Hall of Famer — Tommy Armour's Impact No. 2 delivers a classic heel-toe weighted design with a soft face insert at the most accessible price point in our putter rankings.
Category ratings
What the community loves
The Tommy Armour Impact No. 2 follows the traditional heel-toe weighted blade geometry that has been used in putters since the 1960s — a shape that works for moderate arc strokes and is immediately recognizable to any golfer. At $150, it is one of the most affordable ways to get a proper blade putter rather than a cheap mallet. Golf Monthly noted that 'the Impact No. 2 gets the fundamentals right — the head shape and weight distribution are functional and time-tested, and the finish is cleaner than the price suggests.'
The Impact No. 2's face insert uses a soft elastomer material that promotes forward roll on impact — a meaningful step up from entry-level putters with bare stainless faces that tend to skid the ball initially. Today's Golfer found the roll quality 'serviceable and honest' for the price point, noting that golfers upgrading from a starter-set putter will likely notice an improvement. The insert keeps the cost low while delivering the core performance function of a face insert: reducing skid.
At $150, the Impact No. 2 is the lowest-priced way to own a named-brand blade putter from a recognizable golf company with a legitimate historical legacy. Tommy Armour — a three-time major winner and Golf Hall of Famer — remains a meaningful brand in budget golf equipment. Forum users note the brand recognition adds a sense of legitimacy that generic off-brand putters at similar prices don't provide, and retail reviews show a high satisfaction rate among beginners and casual golfers who just need a functional blade.
The Impact series comes in a small selection of finishes including satin silver, black, and limited seasonal colorways. While this isn't the deep customization available from PING or Titleist, it allows some golfers to match aesthetics or personal preference at no additional cost. Retail reviews showed a preference for the black finish, with purchasers noting it had a 'cleaner, more premium look than the silver at the same price point.'
What to watch out for
The Wilson Infinite Buckingham at $30 more delivers face milling technology, an oversized grip, and a higher-MOI design that the Tommy Armour cannot match. Multiple forum comparisons found the Tommy Armour performing below the Wilson and below Odyssey and Cleveland budget options in the $150-200 range. GolfWRX users who directly compared the Impact No. 2 to budget alternatives from recognized putter brands consistently chose to spend slightly more. The Tommy Armour's value proposition relies on price alone rather than price-per-performance.
The Impact No. 2's casting shows visible finish inconsistencies that premium brands eliminate through quality control. The insert material is soft but thin, and forum users noted that the putter 'feels light in the hand in a way that doesn't inspire confidence.' Golf Monthly's testing found the impact sound 'clunky and unmemorable — not offensive, just undistinguished.' For golfers who have swung premium putters, the Tommy Armour's build quality will feel like what it is: a $150 putter.
The Impact No. 2 has limited coverage across independent review sources — there are fewer expert reviews, fewer forum discussions, and less data-driven testing than any other putter in our rankings. This is reflected in our moderate confidence level. The score is based on the sources available, but golfers should interpret the Tommy Armour's rating with awareness that the sample is smaller than for premium brands.
Tommy Armour operates primarily as a value brand with off-the-shelf stock configurations. There is no fitting program, no adjustable features, and limited grip upgrade support. The Impact No. 2 is a 'what you see is what you get' purchase — a functional blade at the lowest price tier, with no pathway to customization if the stock configuration doesn't match your exact setup needs.
Is it right for your game?
The Tommy Armour Impact No. 2 earns its lowest-in-rankings score honestly — it's an entry-level blade that does the fundamentals without distinction. Expert reviewers note it gets the geometry and insert basics right; forum users who've compared it to slightly more expensive alternatives universally recommend spending $30 more for the Wilson Infinite Buckingham or $50-80 more for budget Odyssey or Cleveland options. The Tommy Armour is a first-step putter for complete beginners, not a long-term investment.
What real people are saying
8 quotes from across the web, grouped by 4 themes. Click a theme to read the individual quotes.
Specifications
Available shafts (no upcharge)
Premium shafts available at additional cost: Graphite Design Tour AD VF, Tour AD UB, Tour AD DI
All sources analyzed
This review synthesizes opinions from 8 independent sources. Every claim on this page can be traced back to its original source. No manufacturer relationship or compensation.
The consensus score is built in four layers: raw source collection, normalization to a 0-10 scale, credibility-weighted combination, and quality adjustments.
Expert reviews (35% weight) are scored from language intensity and any numerical ratings provided. Data-driven testing (25%) converts product rank within the test group to a percentile score. Forum posts (30%) are AI-classified by sentiment, weighted by substantiveness. Retail reviews (10%) convert 5-star ratings with a 0.75x credibility discount to correct for systematic inflation.
Three quality adjustments are then applied: a source diversity bonus (up to +0.3 for coverage across all source types), a conflict penalty (up to -0.3 when sources strongly disagree), and recency weighting (recent reviews weighted higher than older ones).