Scotty Cameron Super Select Newport 2.5 Plus Putter
The wider-flanged 'tweener' that bridges blade and mallet — a forgiving mid-mallet shape with classic Scotty Cameron feel, premium milling, and enough stability to rescue lag putts without overwhelming at address.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link — it never affects our scores or the price you pay.
The consensus
The Scotty Cameron Super Select Newport 2.5 Plus is the wider-flanged 'tweener' that gives blade lovers a taste of mallet forgiveness without abandoning the classic Newport profile. Built from 303 stainless steel with a precision-milled 6061 aircraft-grade aluminum sole plate, the 2.5 Plus sits at a unique size between the Newport 2 and the Squareback 2 — what Cameron calls an 'inbetweener.' Across 12 sources spanning expert reviews, data-driven testing, forums, and retail feedback, the Newport 2.5 Plus earns consistent praise for its forgiveness, premium feel, and lag putting stability. Golf Monthly awarded it 4.9 out of 5 stars, Today's Golfer gave the Super Select line a perfect 5/5, and Golf Digest included it in its 2024 Hot List Gold for blade putters.
Where sources agree most strongly: forgiveness and lag putting. The wider head and perimeter weighting deliver noticeably better stability on off-center strikes compared to traditional blades, and multiple testers found it excelled from 30+ feet where the added mass helps control pace and keep the ball on line. The dual-milled solid face provides the premium, responsive feel golfers expect from Cameron — honest feedback on strike quality without any harshness. The I-beam jet neck is a distinctive design that promotes toe flow for arcing strokes, and the overall build quality reinforces the premium price point.
Where the consensus fractures: value and stroke fit. At $449, the Newport 2.5 Plus commands a significant premium over blades from Ping, Cleveland, and Odyssey that offer comparable or even superior forgiveness at $200-350. Forum users regularly debate whether the Scotty premium is justified by performance or simply brand cachet and resale value. The I-beam jet neck also limits the audience — the substantial toe flow works beautifully for arcing strokes but is a poor match for straight-back, straight-through players, and unlike the Phantom line's four hosel configurations, the Newport 2.5 Plus offers only one setup. Players who prefer insert-based putters may also find the solid stainless steel face firmer than modern alternatives. This is a putter for golfers who prioritize craftsmanship, classic aesthetics, and an arcing stroke — and who are willing to pay the Cameron premium for it.
The wider-flanged 'tweener' that bridges blade and mallet — a forgiving mid-mallet shape with classic Scotty Cameron feel, premium milling, and enough stability to rescue lag putts without overwhelming at address.
Category ratings
What the community loves
The Newport 2.5 Plus sits at a unique size between the Newport 2 and the Squareback 2, creating what Scotty Cameron calls an 'inbetweener.' Golf Monthly found it 'very forgiving for a blade' with the wider body keeping the ball on line even on off-center strikes. The 6061 aircraft-grade aluminum sole plate frees up mass for perimeter weighting, and the result is a blade that behaves more like a mid-mallet on mishits while maintaining the compact look blade players prefer.
The dual-milled 303 stainless steel face delivers the soft, responsive feedback that defines the Cameron brand. Golf Monthly rated the feel and feedback as 'superb,' and the solid-face design produces a muted yet authoritative impact that multiple testers described as best-in-class for blade putters. The dual milling removes weight from the face that gets repositioned to the perimeter without sacrificing the feel golfers expect.
Multiple reviewers singled out lag putting as a standout strength. Golf Monthly testing found the wider head kept the ball along the target line with tight dispersion from over 30 feet, and the added stability compared to standard Newport models was immediately noticeable. The heavier head weight and wider flange help golfers control pace on longer putts where lighter blades tend to feel less predictable.
The Super Select line continues Cameron's reputation for jewelry-level craftsmanship. The milled flange sight line provides a clean alignment cue, the I-beam jet neck is a distinctive design element, and the overall finish quality reinforces the premium positioning. National Club Golfer noted the Super Select Newports keep designs elegantly simple without overcomplicating aesthetics.
What to watch out for
At $449, the Newport 2.5 Plus costs $100-200 more than comparable blade putters from Ping, Cleveland, and Odyssey. Forum users consistently question whether the Scotty premium is justified by performance alone, noting that competing blades offer similar forgiveness at lower price points. The Cameron name, resale value, and craftsmanship partially offset the price, but value-focused golfers will find better forgiveness-per-dollar elsewhere.
Golf Monthly flagged the Pistolini Plus grip as a potential downside, noting the thinner profile may not please all golfers. Mid-size and oversize grip players will need an aftermarket swap immediately, adding to the total cost of ownership. This is a common criticism across the Super Select line.
The sculpted I-beam jet neck promotes substantial toe flow, making this putter best suited for arcing strokes. Golfers with straight-back, straight-through strokes may find the toe hang pulls the face open. Unlike the Phantom line with multiple hosel options, the Newport 2.5 Plus comes in one configuration, limiting fitting flexibility.
While the dual-milled 303 stainless steel face delivers classic Scotty feel, it is firmer than insert-based competitors like the Odyssey Ai-ONE or the 2026 Phantom line's Studio Carbon Steel insert. Players migrating from insert putters may find the solid face too firm, especially on fast greens where a softer impact feel aids confidence.
Is it right for your game?
The Newport 2.5 Plus occupies an interesting middle ground in the Scotty Cameron lineup — wider and more forgiving than the Newport 2, more compact and feedback-rich than the full-size mallets. The community consensus is that it lives up to the Scotty Cameron feel and quality standard at a price that makes sense for a premium blade-mallet hybrid. The main debate is whether the forgiveness improvement over the Newport 2 is meaningful enough to justify choosing it over the classic shape for players who already putt well.
What real people are saying
11 quotes from across the web, grouped by 5 themes. Click a theme to read the individual quotes.
Specifications
Available shafts (no upcharge)
Premium shafts available at additional cost: Graphite Design Tour AD VF, Tour AD UB, Tour AD DI
All sources analyzed
This review synthesizes opinions from 12 independent sources. Every claim on this page can be traced back to its original source. No manufacturer relationship or compensation.
The consensus score is built in four layers: raw source collection, normalization to a 0-10 scale, credibility-weighted combination, and quality adjustments.
Expert reviews (35% weight) are scored from language intensity and any numerical ratings provided. Data-driven testing (25%) converts product rank within the test group to a percentile score. Forum posts (30%) are AI-classified by sentiment, weighted by substantiveness. Retail reviews (10%) convert 5-star ratings with a 0.75x credibility discount to correct for systematic inflation.
Three quality adjustments are then applied: a source diversity bonus (up to +0.3 for coverage across all source types), a conflict penalty (up to -0.3 when sources strongly disagree), and recency weighting (recent reviews weighted higher than older ones).