PXG Battle Ready II Apache Putter
PXG's biggest, most stable mallet — its 7,717 g·cm² MOI is the highest measured of any putter on the market (35.4% beyond TaylorMade's Spider Tour), earning a Golf Digest 2026 Hot List Silver and a 5-star Today's Golfer score, though a lumbering feel on long putts, a heavy head and polarizing looks keep it niche.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link — it never affects our scores or the price you pay.
The consensus
The PXG Battle Ready II Apache is the high-MOI flagship of PXG's nine-model Battle Ready II putter line and, on paper, the most forgiving putter you can buy. Its PXG-published MOI of 7,717 g·cm² is the highest measured figure on the market — 35.4% beyond TaylorMade's Spider Tour and 39% above the next-most-stable model in PXG's own range — made possible by a thin-walled hollow body that frees up mass to push to the perimeter, paired with an ultra-thin 0.055" pyramid-milled face over an S COR polymer core. It is currently shipping, and the Battle Ready II line earned a Silver medal on Golf Digest's 2026 Hot List for mallet putters.
Where the sources agree: forgiveness, alignment and feel. Today's Golfer gave it a full 5 stars and called it “a beast,” and Plugged In Golf confirmed you can strike the ball almost anywhere on the face without the head twisting off line. Reviewers praised how cleanly PXG hid such a large footprint behind a sleek shape and a bold single sightline, and — despite all the engineering — the impact reads as a soft, traditional “tock.” The depth of fitting is a genuine differentiator too: four hosels (including a toe-hang Plumber's Neck), adjustable weights, custom length/lie/loft, and steel, graphite or M16 shafts mean it can be dialed to an arcing stroke, not just a straight one.
Where the consensus fractures: distance control, weight and brand. In an ironic twist for a forgiveness putter, Plugged In Golf found the big, heavy head a little lumbering on long putts and admitted to struggling with lag distance control — the clearest knock against it. At 375–395g it is the heaviest mallet in the line and won't suit players who like a light putter, the styling is polarizing (GolfWRX likened it to a Phantom X 12), and at $389.99 list it comes from a brand still establishing its putter credentials. With fewer fully-tested independent reviews than mainstream mallets, our confidence is moderate. But for a mid-to-high handicapper who wants the absolute most stable head money can buy — especially at today's discounted street prices — the Apache delivers a real, measurable forgiveness edge that nothing else on this list can match.
PXG's biggest, most stable mallet — its 7,717 g·cm² MOI is the highest measured of any putter on the market (35.4% beyond TaylorMade's Spider Tour), earning a Golf Digest 2026 Hot List Silver and a 5-star Today's Golfer score, though a lumbering feel on long putts, a heavy head and polarizing looks keep it niche.
Category ratings
What the community loves
This is the entire reason the Apache exists. PXG publishes its MOI at 7,717 g·cm² — a figure Today's Golfer corroborated as 35.4% higher than TaylorMade's Spider Tour and 27.5% higher than the larger Spider S, and PXG says it is 39% more forgiving than the next-highest model in the Battle Ready II line itself. The thin-walled hollow body lets PXG push mass to the perimeter, and reviewers across the board confirmed the head simply does not twist on mishits. Plugged In Golf summed up the experience: you can strike the ball almost anywhere on the face at almost any speed and not feel the putter move off line.
The Apache is a large mallet, but the consensus is that PXG hid the bulk well. Today's Golfer praised the sleek shape “without too many angles to confuse the eyes” and a bold single sightline, noting the black back wings are cleverly disguised to mask their size. Plugged In Golf agreed the extreme footprint is balanced by a very clean address picture — the aggressive silver taper makes it feel like an arrow aimed at the cup. Golf Digest's Hot List panel called the monochromatic look confidence-inspiring and easy to align.
Despite the engineered pyramid-milled face (just 0.055" thick) and the S COR polymer core, reviewers found the impact feel reassuringly conventional. Plugged In Golf described a very soft feel and a medium-volume “tock,” and MyGolfSpy noted that striking a urethane ball you would never guess how much technology sits behind the face. The S COR fill (roughly 68% of the head in the Apache) dampens vibration while still letting the strike read as a classic, soft mallet impact.
Unlike most super-stable mallets, the Apache is fully fitted to order. Buyers choose from four hosels — Double Bend, Plumber's Neck, Heel-Shafted and Armlock — which meaningfully changes the toe hang, plus custom length, lie and loft, adjustable 2.5–20g sole weights, multiple grip sizes, and steel, graphite or the optional M16 shaft. Today's Golfer highlighted the four hosel options as a real fitting advantage, and Plugged In Golf called out the breadth of weight and grip choices.
The Battle Ready II line earned a Silver medal on Golf Digest's 2026 Hot List for mallet putters — independent third-party validation of the build quality and roll. And while the $389.99 MSRP is premium, the Apache is now widely discounted at retailers like 2nd Swing (often around $199–$220), which materially improves the value equation for a putter that out-forgives anything in its price class.
What to watch out for
The most candid knock, and an ironic one for a forgiveness putter. Plugged In Golf's Matt Saternus found that a head this large and stable feels a little lumbering on long putts and openly admitted he struggled with distance control from range. The very mass and stability that crush short-putt mishits can blunt the touch and feedback that lag putting relies on — a real trade-off buyers should test before committing.
The Apache is the heaviest putter in the Battle Ready II family, with stock head weights of 375–395g depending on the neck (and even the lightest configuration around 345g). Plugged In Golf was explicit: if you favor a lighter putter, you'll need to look elsewhere. The weight is part of how the head stays so planted, but golfers used to a lighter, more reactive feel may fight it.
The Apache's size and aesthetic divide opinion. GolfWRX forum members likened the shape to a Scotty Cameron Phantom X 12 with a half-shaft offset, and PXG's skull branding plus the sheer footprint won't suit traditionalists. Even Golf Digest's panel noted a few testers found the impact firmer and louder than the softest mallets. It's a confident, modern look — but unmistakably a love-it-or-leave-it one.
At $389.99 list, the Apache sits at the top of the putter market, and Today's Golfer flagged that PXG is not yet established as a premier putter manufacturer the way Scotty Cameron, Odyssey or TaylorMade are. Independent, fully-tested review coverage of this specific model is also thinner than for mainstream mallets, which is why our confidence here is moderate rather than high.
Is it right for your game?
What real people are saying
13 quotes from across the web, grouped by 6 themes. Click a theme to read the individual quotes.
Specifications
Available shafts (no upcharge)
Premium shafts available at additional cost: Graphite Design Tour AD VF, Tour AD UB, Tour AD DI
All sources analyzed
This review synthesizes opinions from 7 independent sources. Every claim on this page can be traced back to its original source. No manufacturer relationship or compensation.
The consensus score is built in four layers: raw source collection, normalization to a 0-10 scale, credibility-weighted combination, and quality adjustments.
Expert reviews (35% weight) are scored from language intensity and any numerical ratings provided. Data-driven testing (25%) converts product rank within the test group to a percentile score. Forum posts (30%) are AI-classified by sentiment, weighted by substantiveness. Retail reviews (10%) convert 5-star ratings with a 0.75x credibility discount to correct for systematic inflation.
Three quality adjustments are then applied: a source diversity bonus (up to +0.3 for coverage across all source types), a conflict penalty (up to -0.3 when sources strongly disagree), and recency weighting (recent reviews weighted higher than older ones).