Scotty Cameron Super Select Newport 2.5 Plus Putter
The wider-flanged 'tweener' that bridges blade and mallet — a forgiving mid-mallet shape with classic Scotty Cameron feel, premium milling, and enough stability to rescue lag putts without overwhelming at address.
The consensus
The Scotty Cameron Super Select Newport 2.5 Plus is the wider-flanged 'tweener' that gives blade lovers a taste of mallet forgiveness without abandoning the classic Newport profile. Built from 303 stainless steel with a precision-milled 6061 aircraft-grade aluminum sole plate, the 2.5 Plus sits at a unique size between the Newport 2 and the Squareback 2 — what Cameron calls an 'inbetweener.' Across 12 sources spanning expert reviews, data-driven testing, forums, and retail feedback, the Newport 2.5 Plus earns consistent praise for its forgiveness, premium feel, and lag putting stability. Golf Monthly awarded it 4.9 out of 5 stars, Today's Golfer gave the Super Select line a perfect 5/5, and Golf Digest included it in its 2024 Hot List Gold for blade putters.
Where sources agree most strongly: forgiveness and lag putting. The wider head and perimeter weighting deliver noticeably better stability on off-center strikes compared to traditional blades, and multiple testers found it excelled from 30+ feet where the added mass helps control pace and keep the ball on line. The dual-milled solid face provides the premium, responsive feel golfers expect from Cameron — honest feedback on strike quality without any harshness. The I-beam jet neck is a distinctive design that promotes toe flow for arcing strokes, and the overall build quality reinforces the premium price point.
Where the consensus fractures: value and stroke fit. At $449, the Newport 2.5 Plus commands a significant premium over blades from Ping, Cleveland, and Odyssey that offer comparable or even superior forgiveness at $200-350. Forum users regularly debate whether the Scotty premium is justified by performance or simply brand cachet and resale value. The I-beam jet neck also limits the audience — the substantial toe flow works beautifully for arcing strokes but is a poor match for straight-back, straight-through players, and unlike the Phantom line's four hosel configurations, the Newport 2.5 Plus offers only one setup. Players who prefer insert-based putters may also find the solid stainless steel face firmer than modern alternatives. This is a putter for golfers who prioritize craftsmanship, classic aesthetics, and an arcing stroke — and who are willing to pay the Cameron premium for it.
The wider-flanged 'tweener' that bridges blade and mallet — a forgiving mid-mallet shape with classic Scotty Cameron feel, premium milling, and enough stability to rescue lag putts without overwhelming at address.